18 Comments
User's avatar
Benjamin Magro's avatar

I couldn’t agree more. I think a lot of us feel the way you do here but just don’t say it. Thanks for saying it.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

That's my job, Ben.

Expand full comment
Greg Rohloff's avatar

I don't remember the source, but the gist of the study is that each generation thinks the music that was popular from age 18-25 was the best music ever.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Seems right, Greg!

Expand full comment
Christine's avatar

Thanks, Richard! I love this. Have you seen her documentary?

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thanks, Christine. No, I haven't seen it. Worth watching?

Expand full comment
Cindy Eldridge's avatar

The documentary is well worth watching. She’s quite an astute business woman from a very young age.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I'll look it up. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Marina Osipova's avatar

Loved your arguments, Richard. Now I want to listen to Taylor Swift's music. Never before. I prefer Beethoven and Chaikovsky (smile).

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Haha. You can listen to all of them!

Expand full comment
Kaylene's avatar

Wow, so many thoughts on this. I am so unplugged from popular culture these days that I'm not sure I've ever heard a song by Taylor Swift. (Gasp.) Now I'll have to listen. King's definition of a hack is great. I loved his book on writing. Reading just one of King's books cured me forever of reading or watching horror. He's a genius. Your thoughts on gatekeepers who determine the value of art are so true. What has ever been built or created or accomplished through cynicism? And why does the world so easily defer to it? It would interesting to make a list of artists who became well-known for their work only posthumously. Vincent Van Gogh and Emily Dickinson come to mind.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I couldn't agree more! Cynicism is the worst. I can't say you'll like Taylor Swift! I love that Kobe did!

Expand full comment
Nancy Harmon Jenkins's avatar

My grandson, aged 16, is a big fan of Stephen King, puts him right up there with Cormac McCarthy. That's pretty high praise and he has convinced me that I have to read McCarthy, whom I've always avoided because of his reputed grim stories. As for King, the scariest story I have ever read in my long reading life was one he published in The New Yorker.

But Grandson has never read Shakespeare, not even in a school assignment. Call me an elitist, but that really bothers me. How can you get up to 3rd year in high school without any Shakespeare?

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Now, that just seems wrong, not having read any Shakespeare by 3rd year in high school. I did not like the one McCarthy book I read, "The Road." Very cynical, and I don't like cynicism. I love Stephen King's book "On Writing." Haven't read much more!

Expand full comment
olivier's avatar

Spot on, Richard. I enjoyed reading this because everything you share is always good, but also because this story is a clear reminder that I can be guilty of similar dismissive reactions at times. I hear myself being too judgmental and then question where the reaction is coming from. Am I simply nostalgic for my youth? Have I even given this new artist proper attention before I called them derivative or boring? Part of aging for me comes with the challenge of keeping an open mind. I am aware of it and admire people like you who seem to practice that naturally.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I have the same reactions! I don't want to be one of those bores who says, essentially, "In my day..." Is there an equivalent French expression? Thanks for your response. It always means a lot. By the way, the photo of your new song--haven't listened yet--looks great. All those mountains in the background!

Expand full comment
olivier's avatar

Yes, they say "De mon temps..." Merci pour ta réponse. Toujours un plaisir de te lire.

Glad you like the photo with the Baronnies in the background. I remembered your suggestion and included subtitles this time. Should be pretty easy to follow Hugo's verses.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jun 16, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I totally agree, Elyse.

Expand full comment