26 Comments
User's avatar
Marina Osipova's avatar

A touching story. And yes, the book is still being sold and read 50 years later! This is a bigger recognition than the Pulitzer Prize (IMO).

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I agree!

Expand full comment
olivier's avatar

Beautiful story. Love to see the letter as well. You'll have to come to the Baronnies Provençales!

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thanks, Olivier. I'm packing already!

Expand full comment
Martha Goodman's avatar

This is a lovely piece! I'm going to look for the book and take it with me this summer. The only better thing would be to have you with us! Fingers still crossed...somehow!

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thank you, Martha! Your place isn’t terribly far from where his village is.

Expand full comment
PHILIPPE MISTELI's avatar

Mon cher Richard , always a delight to read you. I fondly remember when I visited you in the south of France but can’t recall how the villagers reacted at that time. I obviously enjoyed reading French Dirt. Coming to Paris soon you will experience how the Parisians react to foreigners and in particular Americans. Don’t hold your breath ; let’s simply enjoy what the city has to offer

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Philippe, I am ready and eager! See you in a few months!

Expand full comment
Nancy Harmon Jenkins's avatar

Richard, I too loved Laurene Wylie's book and have re-read it several times. I actually audited a few sessions of Wylie's course at Harvard when a friend was taking it. That was back in the late 1950's so the book and his experiences were still very much present. As you know, I've also experienced European village life very directly and Wylie's book, as well as yours (French Dirt, you never mentioned the title!), have both meant a great deal to me. Like Wylie, like you, I'm tired of cute Eurovillagers with their quaint ways as depicted in Mayles and Mayes. You go so far beyond that. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thank you, Nancy. Praise coming from you is something I treasure. I didn't mention my title, because I wanted this to be all about Wylie's book. Will you be going to Italy any time soon?

Expand full comment
Nancy Harmon Jenkins's avatar

There's a phrase in Italian I find myself using more and more lately. It's "magari" and best translated as "would that it were!"

Expand full comment
Helayne Spivak's avatar

What a lovely story. And what a lovely thing to do. Let someone know they made a difference in someone else's life.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thanks so much, Helayne. I so appreciate your words.

Expand full comment
Patty Riddlebarger's avatar

Beautiful piece. There’s nothing quite like the power of appreciation from someone whom you admire. Early in my career I was an executive speechwriter. I had an opportunity to write for a motley crew of Fortune 500 CEOs and politicians from mayors to governors. Only one took the time to send a personal, hand-written thank you note for the words I crafted for her. It’s closing on 40 years. And I have it still.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thanks, Patty, for reading this and taking the time to write. Yes, what a few words of appreciation can do! And it doesn't take that much effort!

Expand full comment
Roy Burkhead, MFA's avatar

Of course, I'm going to read this book. But I can't imagine it will be as good as your Provence adventures. :-)

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

It is!

Expand full comment
Elizabeth Godfrey's avatar

How wonderful to get that genuine response from him. Now I'll have to hunt up his book---and reread yours. I loved it the first time.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Many thanks, Elizabeth.

Expand full comment
Margaret Keeping's avatar

Oh Richard, what a wonderful letter and how felicitous that you took the trouble to write to him. He was right about French Dirt - I've said often what a masterpiece of it's kind it is. Looks like Americans are better on France and the French than we Brits, perhaps because of ancient rivalries and consequent caricatures.

Thanks so much for sharing this- now I'll look for the Wylie book.

Expand full comment
Margaret Keeping's avatar

Just want to edit that ' it's ' !

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

I make that mistake all the time! I'm glad you liked the piece, Margaret. Thanks so much for letting me know. And for the kind words about FD.

Expand full comment
Brian Willson's avatar

Wonderful. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Glad you liked it, Brian.

Expand full comment
Cara Prieskorn's avatar

You were that writing teacher for me. You had more influence on my writing than any other person and I’ve have some great teachers, but you are the best. Still hoping to make you proud.

Expand full comment
Richard Goodman's avatar

Thank you so much, Cara. That's kind of you. I so enjoy hearing from you.

Expand full comment